Thursday, January 22, 2026

Lost in Space

There are many parameters in the computer code that I've written to generate musical scores. Really the whole program is one big parameter! Someday maybe I will have a single program that can read a parameter file, so there will be a clear distinction between the code and the parameters that control it. But what I do instead is just edit the program itself for each new piece.

The program uses a random number generator to decide many of the details in the score. The random number generator is controlled by a seed. I can just change the seed to get multiple pieces that are all similar, with the same gross structure.

A fundamental parameter is the tuning system. I have some code that can work with more general tuning systems, but most of the code is limited to dividing octaves into some number of equal steps. So the number of steps per octave is a fundamental parameter. The piece linked below uses the tuning system where octaves are divided into 53 equal steps.

A table of interval scores is constructed based on a set of prime numbers. So another parameter is the prime numbers that are to define consonance. The primes 2, 3, and 5 are a common choice, which is used in the piece linked below. Sometimes I will add the prime 7. So far the largest prime I have used is 19, but the code isn't really limited. The construction of the interval score table does slow down as the number of primes increases, though. The table construction code has some other paramters that I'll tweak. The program writes the table to a file, so I can check that file to see if the table looks reasonable. If it doesn't, I can tweak some parameters in the code to make the table look better. Mostly it's just a matter of getting a good range of scores, so some intervals will be much preferred over other intervals. But the range shouldn't be too extreme, or the pitch selection algorithm can get stuck too easily.

The rhythmic topology is another key parameter. The basic rhythmic parameters are the length of each measure and the number of measures. The measures are arranged in a cubical array of arbitrary dimensionality. In the piece linked below, each measure is about 35 seconds long, and there are 64 measures, arranged as a 4x4x4 array.

Measures are divided into individual notes of varying length. I have used several different algorithms to divide up measures, each of which has multiple parameters.

The number of voices in the piece is another parameter. Here I am using 3 voices.

That's a sketch of the control I have over what gets generated! Here's the latest output: 53edo 4x4x4 scale 34.

Saturday, January 17, 2026

Neutral Thirds

I saw some discussion on a facebook tuning group about neutral thirds in Persian music, attributed to Mansour Zalzal in the 9th Century. A neutral third is between a major third and a minor third. Since a major third and a minor third combine to form a perfect fifth, a neutral third should be about half of a perfect fifth. Zalzal evidently proposed 27:22 as a neutral third. Squaring this gives 729:484. A perfect fifth would be 726:484, so Zalzal's neutral third is quite accurate.

This looked worth exploring. What equal divisions of the octave work well with ratios involving the prime number 11? 87edo is very good, but it is a bit strange: it doesn't temper the schisma, it has three circles of fifths, etc. 65edo looks good, though!

The Persian scales discussed in the tuning group have 17 notes per octave. The neutral third corresponds to 19 steps of 65edo, or 19\65. A 17 note scale generated by neutral thirds has the Moment of Symmetry property, e.g. the scale has two different step sizes: 3\65 and 5\65.

This is a table of the 17 notes, in terms of cents.

Here's an example of what it sounds like: 65edo scale 17.

Friday, January 9, 2026

114edo Tweak

In yesterday's post I mentioned that the scale there could probably get straightened out a bit, so that's what I did. The simpler structure has a simpler description, too! The scale is built of two similar sequences generated by the interval of 5 steps of 114edo. The pitch classes in the scale thus go 0, 5, 10, 15, ..., 55, and then 57, 62, 67, 72, ..., 112. So there are two intervals of 2 steps seperating the two sequences of 5 steps. The tonnetz diagram above looks much the same as yesterday's, but just a little more symmetric.

I made a new piece with this tweaked scale: 114edo 24b. I used a somewhat different process to make this. Both today's and yesterday's piece use my usual thermodynamic algorithm. Yesterday I started the simulation at a very high temperature and gradually cooled in until global order emerged spontaneously. The piece is a snapshot from around the transition temperature. In today's simulation, I just fixed the temperature at the transition temperature that I observed in yesterday's piece. I initialized the system with a traversal of the comma 245:243. This traversal is repeated eight times over the course of the piece.

Thursday, January 8, 2026

114edo

I've been exploring diaschismic tunings, tunings that temper out the diaschisma comma, 2048:2025. 2025 = 25 * 81, so the comma gets tempered by making both perfect fifths and major thirds a bit sharp. A few days ago I looked at 90edo, which has a perfect fifth sharp enough to do all the work, leaving the major third very close to just. Today's exploration is 114edo, which has perfect fifths and major thirds equally sharp, sharing the workload.

Looking at the tuning errors of 114edo, in the upper left area one can see that 3:1 and 5:1, corresponding to perfect fifths and major thirds, are not so accurate, being sharp enough to temper out the diaschisma. Since they are equally sharp, minor thirds, 5:3, are quite precise. But what jumped out at me with this table of errors is that 114edo has a quite accurate approximation for 7:1. That should spice things up!

Staring at the tonnetz diagram for a while and contemplating 7:1 which corresponds to 92 steps of 114... well, two steps of 7:1 would be 70 steps, which comes back near the the starting point. This corresponds to the comma 245:243, which I see people call the minor Bohlen-Pierce diesis. I looked for a scale that would support traversals of this and the diaschisma. I came up with the 24 note scale highlighted above. This is the union of two scales generated by the interval of 62 steps of 114edo, the two scales offset by 67 steps. As I have thought more about this, probably offsetting the scales by 5 steps would have been better, but I got pretty far down the road with the 67 step offset, so that's what I have here.

The tonnetz diagram layout shows perfect fifths, moving from a cell to its neighbor on the right, and major thirds, moving from a cell to its neighbor above. I used colors to show movement by 7:1. Each blue cell can move to a purple cell by a 7:1 interval. So an example of a traversal of 245:243 would be to start at a (blue) 0 cell and leap to a (purple) 92 cell, moving with a 7:1 interval. Then move by two perfect fourths, stepping left two cells, to a (blue) 72 cell. Leap by 7:1 again to a (purple) 50 cell. From there, move left three cells, three perfect fourths, to a 77 cell, and then up one cell, a major third, which brings one back to a 0 cell where the traversal started.

Here's what the scale sounds like: 114edo scale 24.

Tuesday, January 6, 2026

90edo Diaschismic

I have posted some music in the past that uses 34edo, a tuning system that has very good approximations for conventional intervals like perfect fifths and major thirds. But 34edo does not temper out the syntonic comma 81:80; instead it tempers out the diaschisma 2048:2025. The diagram above is a tonnetz diagram for diaschismic tuning of the conventional 12 notes of a piano.

Conventional music, in the Palestrina - Wagner tradition, is built on tempering the syntonic comma, which is the foundation of meantone tunings. The tonnetz diagram for meantone tuning looks quite different:

There is a spectrum of meantone tunings, where the flatness of the perfect fifth is traded against the sharpness of the major third. 31edo, or quarter comma meantone, are at one end of the spectrum, where the major thirds are quite precise while the perfect fifth is rather flat. It occurred to me that the same sort of spectrum should exist for diaschismic tunings.

Perfect fifths are a bit sharper than just, in diaschismic tunings. There are two wolf fifths, D-A and Ab-Eb in the tonnetz diagram. These are flat, to make for the sharpness of most of the fifths. As the fifths are sharpened, most of the major thirds get flatter. When the fifths get to around 707 cents (versus the just fifth of 702 cents), the major thirds become just, at 386 cents. There are wolf major thirds in this tuning though, such as A-C# in the tonnetz diagram, that sharpen as the fifths sharpen.

It turns out that 90edo has fifths that are close to the value needed to make the major thirds very exact... so of course I had to see what it sounded like: 90edo scale 12.

Monday, December 22, 2025

13edo

To divide octaves into thirteen equal steps: thirteen is very close to twelve, and twelve is the conventional and excellent way to divide octaves, so it might seem that thirteen should work very well too.

Somehow, though, that's not how the math works! This is a table of tuning errors for 13edo: how far off it is from just intonation for a variety of intervals. The number in the upper left, 0.395, is the most fundamental error, the error for perfect fifths. A just tuned perfect fifth lies 39.5% of the way between two of the notes of 13edo. It could hardly be worse!

So, maybe we can try to make some music using intervals that 13edo approximates well. Still focusing on the region of simpler intervals toward the upper left, 9:5 and 11:1 are approximated quite well. Let's try using those as building blocks!

So here is an unconventional tonnetz diagram based on these two intervals. 9:5 is equivalent to 10:9 which is one form of a conventional whole step. 2 steps of 13edo form a interval a bit flatter than 2 steps of 12edo; 10:9 is a bit flatter than 9:8. So far, so good! In the diagram, moving right or left from a cell is moving by 10:9 or 9:5. Moving down is moving by 11:8; moving up is moving by 16:11. These intervals are not conventional at all! They are close to the dissonant tritone: 11:8 is a bit flatter; 16:11 is a bit sharper. Then again, 11:8 is a bit sharper than a perfect fourth, 4:3, and 16:11 is a bit flatter than a perfect fifth, 3:2. This is how 13edo works: it chops the pitch spectrum up in a very different way!

Cells labeled 0 occur in many places. A tonnetz diagram like this is really an unrolled torus. A path from one 0 cell to another 0 cell represents a loop on the torus, which is a traversal of a comma. Starting from one 0 cell, each other 0 cell represents a different comma, a just interval that is quite close to unison. There is a path 0, 2, 4, 6, 0 that corresponding to a traversal of the comma 8019:8000. Extending this path looks like a nice way to build a scale with six notes per octave.

Here's what it sounds like: 13edo steer

Thursday, November 27, 2025

A Kind of Pentatonic

Here is a new piece in 36edo, using a scale with five notes per octave.

This is built from tempered intervals approximating 7:4, or seven steps of 36edo. This is very close to 5edo, i.e. dividing octaves into five equal intervals. Here four of the intervals are seven steps of 36edo, and the fifth intervals is eight steps of 36edo. In the diagram above, this eight step interval is omitted since it acts as a sort of wolf tone.

This scale supports traversal of the comma 1029:1024, i.e. moving by 8:7 three times brings one to a perfect fifth 3:2, folding octaves along the way. The red arrows in the diagram represent intervals of 7:4, and the green arrows are the 3:2 perfect fifths.