Monday, November 24, 2025

Conventionally Unconventional

Here is a new piece in the 31edo tuning system, using a 19 note scale. This scale is built from a chain of perfect fifths, so conventional notation is applicable.

31edo is very close to quarter-comma meantone; that, and a 19 note scale, were used in Renaissance times. But here I am exploiting intervals that approximate just tuned intervals involving the prime number 7. For example, 8:7 is very close to 6 steps of 31edo. This 19 note scale includes many 6 step intervals.

This diagram shows the primary intervals available in this 19 note scale. Green arrows are perfect fifth, blue arrows are major thirds, and red arrows are 7:4 intervals that don't fit well into conventional terminology. Rather than arranging the notes into a circle of fifth, I used a spiral of fifths that prioritizes chains of major thirds. The conventional diatonic scale can be arranged this way, too:

Wednesday, November 19, 2025

12 Note Scale in 31edo

Here is a new piece in 31edo, using a conventional 12 note scale built from a chain of perfect fifths. 31edo has flatter fifths than conventional 12edo, which makes available a reasonable accurate 7:4 interval.

The green arrows here are perfect fifths, the blue arrows are major thirds, and the red arrows are 7:4 intervals which are not conventional diatonic intervals. These red arrows create many new comma traversals, e.g. Eb - G - D - A -C# - Eb.

Tuesday, November 11, 2025

171edo tertiaseptal 31

Here's a new piece in 171edo. The scale here has 31 notes per octave, spaced rather evenly: 5 or 6 steps of 171edo between the notes of the scale. I learned about this scale from a discussion on reddit.

This scale supports traversal of the commas 2401:2400 and 65536:65625. Poking around on the web, I found an email where these commas are discussed and the name tertiaseptal is given to a class of scales that support traversing these commas.

Here is a chart showing tuning errors for 171edo. The numbers on the left and upper margins are the numerators and denominators of ratios for intervals in just intonation. The cells in the center show the tuning error of 171edo, in terms of steps of 171edo. So the maximum error possible is 0.5, where the just interval falls exactly between two steps of 171edo. This chart shows that ratios involving 11 are not approximated very well in 171edo! So for this piece I was prioritizing intervals that approximate ratios involving the primes 2, 3, 5, and 7.

Thursday, November 6, 2025

72edo

Here's a new piece in 72edo. This uses the scale I mentioned a couple days ago, 21 notes per octave generated by the 7 microstep that approximates the semitone 16:15. Conventionally a perfect fifth corresponds to 7 semitones. But if you compare the just tuned perfect fifth, 3:2, to the just tuned semitone, 16:15, the perfect fifth corresponds to 6.28 semitones. In 72edo, the perfect fifth corresponds to 6 semitones. The post here from a couple days ago gets into comma traversals supported by this scale.

This piece is generated by my usual thermodynamic process, where order spontaneously emerges at a phase transition that is marked by a sudden drop in energy or cost:

This new piece is a snapshot of the system at a cost around 10000000, right at the phase transition.

Tuesday, November 4, 2025

Loop Search

Recently I was exploring the 270edo tuning system, and a 90 note scale. I wanted a symmetric scale, which this subset is. I also wanted a scale that would traverse the comma 2080:2079, which includes the primes 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, and 13. I was wondering whether that scale might support traversal of other commas, too. This is a lot of notes in a space of rather high dimensionality! So I wrote a program! I can switch the set of primes, the tuning system, and the scale, all very easily, to explore the possibilities for comma traversals.

The program looks at loops for each note in the scale: sometimes the loops that pass through one note are different than those that pass through a different note. Experimenting with this program, I see that happening sometimes. For this particular 90 note subset of 270edo, each note has the same set of loops:

  • | 12 -2 -1 -1 0 -1 > = 4096:4095
  • | -7 -1 2 0 -1 2 > = 4225:4224
  • | -10 -1 -1 1 0 3 > = 15379:15360
  • | 2 1 -1 -3 1 1 > = 1716:1715
These strings of numbers are the powers of the primes 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, and 13, so they give the prime factorization of the ratios. These commas can be combined arbitrarily to form a whole linear space of commas that can be traversed with this scale. My new program looks for a minimal basis for this space.

This 90 note subset is symmetric: the 270 notes of the tuning system are divided into 10 blocks of 27 notes each. The scale picks out 9 notes from each block, at the same positions in each block. I ran the program with only 8 notes per block: then the sets of commas traversable had a basis of three instead of four commas. When I increased the number of notes per block, some notes had a basis set of five commas. So 9 notes per block does seem like a nice threshold.

Another scale I have explored at some point - I don't remember when! - is a 21 note scale in 72edo, generated by the semitone 16:15. 72edo works well with primes 2, 3, 5, 7, and 11, but not with 13. So I ommitted 13 in this analysis. Again, all the notes in the scale had the same space of commas traversable:

  • | -10 1 0 3 0 > = 1029:1024
  • | -5 2 2 -1 0 > = 225:224
  • | -7 -1 1 1 1 > = 385:384

Wednesday, October 22, 2025

Forget the Commas!

Here's another piece in 270edo. This uses the same scale as the piece I posted yesterday. I wanted to make something with more coherence. The earlier piece is more stretched out: it is built from a 12x12=144 array of measures. For this piece I used a 2x2x2x2x2x2=64 array, i.e. a six dimensional hypercube, with measures a bit more than twice as long. The very short sides of the array mean that comma traversals are almost impossible. The harmonic complexity in this new piece is much more immediate, rather than the result of long paths wandering through the woods!

Tuesday, October 21, 2025

Symmetric Scales

Here is a new piece in 270edo.

This is a graphical score for the piece. The horizontal axis is time, in seconds. The vertical axis is pitch classes, from 0 to 269. All the octaves have been folded into a single octave.

The score shows the scale I used for this piece. This scale is an example of what Olivier Messiaen called a "mode of limited transposition" - I am calling it a symmetric scale. A nice feature of 270edo is that 270 factors very nicely: 270 = 2 x 5 x 27. These factors create opportunities for symmetries: a pattern of notes in or out of the scale can be repeated within an octave. In the scale here, the pattern is 27 pitch classes long, and repeats 10 times in an octave, to cover the full 270 pitch classes. From the 27 pitch classes in the pattern, 9 are in the scale and the other 18 are excluded. The 9 included are a simple sequence of every other pitch class in the scale, every other pitch class out of the scale.

So the complete scale starts with pitch classes 0, 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16, 27, 29, 31, 33, 35, etc.

My goal with this scale was to support traversal of the comma 2080:2079. This comma is not too complicated but it includes all the primes involved in the notion of consonance I imposed for this piece: 2080 = 32 x 5 x 13; 2079 = 27 x 7 x 11. I figured that if a scale could allow traversal of this comma, it could support a rich harmonic language.